Skip to main content
Michigan State University

CHM Clinician Educator Mentoring Program

Collection of helpful resources for those participating in CHM's CEMP program

Appraisal

Appraising literature has many purposes. It can be as simple as scanning titles before reading abstracts to examining in detail the statistical methodologies of articles to determine accuracy.

Looking at the abstract of an article within a database can give you ideas about what keywords and controlled vocabulary describes that article. For a particularity relevant article that can help you refine your search and make it stronger.

Appraising an article, or any information resource, before you download a citation or read it in depth can save you time. You do not want to read an entire research study only to discover its outcomes are irrelevant to your topic. Also, it helps ensure you will not include poorly done research in your project.

Evaluating the Literature

How to Evaluate Journal Articles

Guide from the Colorado State University Libraries on questions to ask when evaluating a journal article.

Critical Appraisal and Analysis

Information from the Cornell University Library on initial appraisal and content analysis that should be applied to information sources.

Locating and Evaluating Scholarly Articles

From the University of Maryland University College Library, ways to identify and locate scholarly articles.

Evaluating Web Pages

Techniques to apply and questions to ask when evaluating web pages from the UC Berkeley Library.

Web Site Evaluation

Annotated list of web site evaluation resources from the MSU Libraries. A number of these tips can be applied to resources other than web pages.

Evaluation Exercises

Evaluation Worksheet

Questions to ask yourself each time you choose a source from your literature search.

Article Comparison Table

Chart adapted from an exercise comparing scholarly vs. popular articles, but contains good questions to ask of all articles.

Michigan State University